Why Did HART Multiplexer Fail During PLC System Migration?

A refinery upgraded its aging Distributed Control System to a modern PLC based automation platform while keeping the existing smart transmitters and HART multiplexer infrastructure for diagnostics and predictive maintenance. After commissioning, operators observed that all pressure, temperature, and flow values were displayed correctly in the PLC and trending normally in the SCADA system. However, the asset management software connected through the HART multiplexer suddenly lost communication with several field instruments.

Maintenance engineers initially suspected transmitter hardware failure because the HART multiplexer could not retrieve device diagnostics, secondary variables, or status alerts. Surprisingly, when technicians connected a handheld HART communicator directly across the transmitter terminals in the field, communication worked perfectly and all transmitter parameters were accessible.

Further investigation revealed that the newly installed PLC analog input cards had very low internal impedance compared to the previous DCS cards. The old DCS input cards naturally provided enough loop resistance for HART communication, while the new PLC cards only supported the analog 4 to 20 mA current signal. Because of this, the HART Frequency Shift Keying signal became too weak for the multiplexer to detect reliably.

The engineering team installed an external 250 Ohm resistor in series with the analog loop. Immediately after adding the resistor, the HART multiplexer restored stable communication with all transmitters, and the AMS software began receiving diagnostics and device health information again.

HART communication failed because the PLC analog input card did not provide sufficient loop impedance for the HART digital signal. HART protocol superimposes digital Frequency Shift Keying signals at 1200 Hz and 2200 Hz on top of the normal 4 to 20 mA analog current loop. While the PLC could still read the analog current correctly, the low impedance input card absorbed or weakened the HART communication signal.

Many older DCS cards include approximately 250 Ohms of loop resistance internally, which is enough for reliable HART communication. However, many modern PLC analog cards use lower resistance values to improve analog measurement accuracy, unintentionally reducing HART communication performance. In some cases, input filters inside the analog card may also attenuate the HART frequencies.

This issue is extremely common during PLC migration projects in process industries where engineers verify only the analog signal operation and forget to validate HART compatibility. Installing a properly sized 250 Ohm resistor restored the required loop impedance, allowing the HART multiplexer to detect transmitter diagnostics, configuration data, and secondary variables successfully. Additional factors such as signal isolators, loop noise, grounding problems, and non HART compatible barriers can also create similar communication failures in industrial plants

Refer the below link for What is HART Multiplexer