ControlNet and EtherNet are both industrial automation communication networks, although they differ in terms of underlying technology, characteristics, and applications. Here is a thorough comparison of ControlNet and EtherNet:
Physical Layer and Technology
ControlNet is a deterministic network with a token-passing bus structure. It communicates via coaxial cable or fibre optic cable, which provides good noise immunity and reliability. ControlNet transmits data at a rate of 5 Mbps.
EtherNet is an Ethernet-based network that adheres to the IEEE 802.3 standard. It communicates via twisted-pair copper cables or fibre optic cables. EtherNet operates at various data rates, the most prevalent being 100 Mbps (Fast Ethernet) and 1 Gbps (Gigabit Ethernet).
Determinism and Data Transfer
ControlNet provides consistent communication, which means it guarantees data transmission within set time intervals. It provides real-time control and synchronization, making it appropriate for sensitive applications requiring exact timing and coordination.
EtherNet provides non-deterministic communication, with data packets transmitted and delivered on a best-effort basis. While EtherNet can provide real-time communication using protocols such as EtherNet/IP, it lacks the determinism of ControlNet. EtherNet is widely used for general-purpose communication and networking.
Speed and Bandwidth
ControlNet has a lower bandwidth than EtherNet. ControlNet, with a data rate of 5 Mbps, is intended for applications that require moderate to high-speed communication but do not require the large bandwidth afforded by EtherNet.
EtherNet offers more bandwidth, including Fast Ethernet (100 Mbps) and Gigabit Ethernet (1 Gbps) possibilities. This higher bandwidth enables faster data transfer and supports high-data-demanding applications such as large-scale data collecting and high-speed control.
Number of nodes supported in a network
When compared to EtherNet, ControlNet supports a lower number of nodes. It is intended for small to medium-sized networks, with up to 99 nodes per network segment. ControlNet networks may require the use of repeaters or segmentation to maintain network performance after a certain number of nodes have been added.
EtherNet, on the other hand, can accommodate a far larger number of nodes. EtherNet networks can support a greater number of devices due to its scalability and flexibility. The exact number of nodes supported varies based on network design, switches, and other factors, although it can range from hundreds to thousands in a single network.
ControlNet often has a linear or tree-like bus topology, with devices daisy-chained together. This topology simplifies network design and wiring, but device location must be carefully considered to provide best performance.
EtherNet offers a wide range of network topologies, such as star, ring, and line configurations. It allows for network design flexibility by allowing devices to be easily added or withdrawn. EtherNet switches are frequently used to connect network segments and increase scalability.
ControlNet is often used in high-speed, deterministic control and synchronization applications such as motion control, drive systems, and process automation. It’s ideal for large-scale distributed control systems (DCS) and applications that require real-time performance.
EtherNet is widely used in industrial automation for general-purpose communication, device integration, and networking. It is suitable for a wide range of applications such as data acquisition, HMI (Human-Machine Interface) communication, remote monitoring, and business connection. EtherNet/IP, an industrial Ethernet protocol built on EtherNet, is widely used in Allen-Bradley products.
Scalability and adaptation
Because ControlNet only supports a limited number of devices per network segment, it is best suited for small to medium-sized networks. To maintain performance, a ControlNet network may be expanded by adding repeaters or segmenting the network.
EtherNet has good scalability, allowing for larger networks with more devices. EtherNet networks can be quickly expanded using switches and routers, accommodating expanding automation requirements.