Safety Integrity Levels (SILs) for Industrial Processes
In the setting of industrial processes and instruments, safety integrity levels (SIL) refer to how well a system or device decreases the risk of hazards. The IEC 61508 and IEC 61511 standards specify SIL, which is utilized to assess the operational safety of electrical, electronic, & programmable electronic systems like transmitters.
Difference between SIL2 & SIL1
Definition
A Safety Integrity Level of 1 (SIL1) indicates the lowest level of safety performance. It signifies that the system provides a minimal level of risk reduction while remaining within acceptable limits for the application.
SIL1: SIL1 indicates a probability of failure on demand (PFD) between 10^-2 & 10^-1.
SIL2: A Safety Integrity Level 2 (SIL2) indicates a greater level of safety performance. The risk reduction is greater than SIL1, & it is commonly utilized in situations requiring a higher level of safety. SIL2 indicates a probability of failure on demand (PFD) between 10^-3 & 10^-2.
Risk Reduction
SIL1 provide basic risk mitigation.
SIL2 provides a greater level of risk mitigation.
Application
SIL1: Typically employed in systems (or) processes where failures are less severe or occur seldom.
SIL2: Typically employed in processes when the implications of a failure are more serious, but the system is not as important as SIL3.
Can a SIL2 rated transmitter be utilized in SIL1 applications?
Yes, a SIL2-rated transmitter can be utilized in a SIL1 application; however, the effects must be understood.
A SIL2-rated transmitter provides a better level of safety than a SIL1 application. While it can be used in SIL1 applications, it can be overly developed for that purpose.
The SIL2 transmitter gives a higher level of risk reduction than is required for a SIL1 system, therefore it is completely appropriate to use in a SIL1 application; however, it may not be cost-effective or mandated by safety regulations.
In fact, utilizing a higher-rated device (such as a SIL2 device in a SIL1 system) can provide more safety margin; nonetheless, it is vital that the complete safety system, not just individual components, fulfill the required SIL level.
Superior Class
A SIL2-rated transmitter outperforms a SIL1-rated transmitter because:
It performs more reliably and safely.
It can provide better risk reduction, making it appropriate for more sensitive applications. A SIL2 transmitter often meets more strict design, testing, & validation requirements than a SIL1 transmitter.
You can also follow us on AutomationForum.co, Facebook and Linkedin to receive daily Instrumentation updates.
You can also follow us on ForumElectrical.com , Facebook and Linkedin to receive daily Electrical updates.