# Comparison between P, PI, PD and PID controllers

**URL:** <https://forumautomation.com/t/comparison-between-p-pi-pd-and-pid-controllers/4922>\
**Category:** Industrial Automation\
**Tags:** control-system\
**Created:** [October 12, 2018, 8:50pm UTC](https://forumautomation.com/t/comparison-between-p-pi-pd-and-pid-controllers/4922 "2018-10-12T20:50:56Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![divyasree](https://forumautomation.com/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/d/edb3f5/32.png) [@divyasree](https://forumautomation.com/u/divyasree)\
**Post date:** [October 12, 2018, 8:50pm UTC](https://forumautomation.com/t/comparison-between-p-pi-pd-and-pid-controllers/4922/1 "2018-10-12T20:50:56Z")

</div>

A review on the composite controllers along with the proportional controller

 ![Screenshot%20(37)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/d/de21c8862505a77a4f9d198a24187bcb72692a84.png)

Considering a unit negative feedback system, with Setpoint - R(S) ,  
Output - C(S) Error signal - E(s) = R(S) - C(S) Manipulated signal - M(S) The type of controller used defines the output of the system. Here, specifically we see the following controllers alone.

**Proportional** ( P ) **Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) **Proportional - Integrated - Differential** ( PID )

## Gain in time domain

**Proportional** ( P ) : ![Screenshot%20(38)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/b/b84c94c5a805d70614473bce79fb4f3d7ee59e65.png) **Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) : ![Screenshot%20(40)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/5/5a9b4049e7a536074daa0781307485000fb4ad28.png) **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) : ![Screenshot%20(39)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/7/7325240354e4136e43fa93719b743980e3e37db6.png) **Proportional - Integrated - Differential** ( PID ) : ![Screenshot%20(44)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/5/5f5b167162c2d5e2b8a646ec5029c51e808a2b81.png)

## Gain in Frequency Domain

**Proportional** ( P ) : ![Screenshot%20(38)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/b/b84c94c5a805d70614473bce79fb4f3d7ee59e65.png) **Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) : ![Screenshot%20(41)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/1/19c20344602cc2f8cdc27c6ca03daa1bf4e33799.png) **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) : ![Screenshot%20(42)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/6/6f5135e83edff17de581f9b9fb47163ea101d788.png) **Proportional - Integrated - Differential** ( PID ) : ![Screenshot%20(43)](https://cdn.forumautomation.com/original/2X/4/4e1ed5f58677b8ab75e2604c31fbbbe550861531.png)

## Advantages:

**Proportional** ( P ) : Speed controlled ( Increase gain)  
**Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) : Good damping, Offset is zero ( because of Integration), No steady state error **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) : Maximum overshoot decreases, Rise time, settling time is reduced , Bandwidth is increased. **Proportional - Integrated - Differential** ( PID ) : Decreases rise time (Kp), Eliminates steady state error (Ki), Decreases overshoot and settling time ( Kd).

## Disadvantages:

**Proportional** ( P ) : Offset issue **Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) : Slow Response, Stability **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) : Offset, Steady state error

## System Filteration

**Proportional** ( P ) : Linear network ( No filteration) **Proportional - Integrated** ( PI ) : Low pass filter **Proportional - Differential** ( PD ) : High pass filter **Proportional - Integrated - Differential** ( PID ) : Band pass or Band reject depending on gain values
